ZURICH (Reuters) - Credit Suisse CSGN.VX boss Brady Dougan has outmaneuvered an internal rival with his recent revamp of the Swiss bank and management shake-up but is still on borrowed time, senior banking sources say.
Dougan might have played his last hand with an overhaul that strengthens the investment bank where the American made his career before taking over as chief executive in 2007 while also promoting two more executives to join the race to succeed him.
“The latest reorganization shows clearly that Dougan remains under immense pressure,” a former high-ranking Credit Suisse banker says. “He will be replaced as soon as a suitable successor is found.”
The Credit Suisse reorganization contrasts with hometown rival UBS UBSN.VX, which is abandoning most fixed-income activities in favor of its flagship private bank as tough Swiss capital rules begin eating into investment banking profits.
Instead, Dougan, who has long defended the unit he used to head from calls for a dramatic scaleback, announced a raft of measures that confirm his desire to keep Credit Suisse at the top table of investment banking.
In an affirmation of his commitment to the fixed income business that UBS is shrinking, Dougan promoted French debt banker Gael de Boissard as investment bank co-head alongside American Eric Varvel, who will also run the Asia-Pacific region.
The asset management business will be integrated into the private banking unit and its American head Robert Shafir appointed co-head alongside private banking boss Hans-Ulrich Meister.
Meister originally pushed for the asset management integration to strengthen his own unit, but Dougan outfoxed him by stalling the move and making his ally Shafir joint head, according to several sources close to the bank.
The private bank that caters to the financial needs of the wealthy had only just engineered a merger of Swiss retail and private banking arms to cut costs but is the “net loser” of the shake up, sources close to the bank said.
“They have been relegated to a supporting role and Meister’s effectively been demoted,” by having to accept a co-head for the unit he ran alone, a former senior Credit Suisse executive said.
The one Swiss banker among the four division heads, Meister had made no secret within Credit Suisse of his ambitions for Dougan’s job. But Americans and investment bankers have gained in influence with the overhaul, deepening a cultural tug-of-war between Credit Suisse’s U.S.-focused investment bank and its less risky and more traditional Swiss-based private bank.
Dougan won praise for steering Credit Suisse through the financial crisis without resorting to a government bailout like UBS but has been criticized for squandering that advantage, drawing an unusual call from the Swiss central bank earlier this year to urgently bolster capital.
He has also drawn fire in Switzerland for spending much of his time in New York and failing to learn German but cemented his position when he marshaled support from key shareholders for a package of measures to boost capital by 15.3 billion Swiss francs in response to the central bank rebuke.
Credit Suisse’s stock is little moved on the year at 22.05 Swiss francs - lagging a 20 percent rise in the European bank index .SX7P and a jump of 30 percent for UBS shares - albeit it up a third from a trough of 15.97 francs hit in August.
“Management is under pressure to deliver,” said JPMorgan & Chase analyst Kian Abouhossein.
He says 2013 is a “make or break” year for Dougan, in which the CEO must cut costs and scale back capital-intensive areas of fixed income such as foreign exchange and commodities.
While Dougan has bought some time with the revamp, his future is still uncertain despite recent public backing by Chairman Urs Rohner, according to sources close to the bank.
Privately, Rohner has been more openly critical, two sources said: “Rohner would’ve replaced Dougan already had there been a suitable alternative,” said one person familiar with Rohner’s thinking.
Though the move raises the profile of Shafir and de Boissard, the four co-heads are considered either too inexperienced or not well enough connected in the Swiss financial establishment, and will need time to prove themselves.
“I don’t think any of them are suited or will ultimately get Dougan’s job, but Rohner has to signal he is thinking seriously about succession,” the top former Credit Suisse banker said.
A Credit Suisse spokesman said Meister, Shafir, Varvel and de Boissard all declined to comment for this story.
“MARRIAGE OF CONVENIENCE”
Dougan managed to outmaneuver Meister in part because the private banking head has not covered himself in glory since taking over the unit last year, according to a senior banker at Credit Suisse.
Meister is perceived as botching the integration of 250-year-old independent boutique Clariden Leu as well as Eurom, an information technology harmonization effort.
Though Meister, a corporate banker who rose through the ranks in a 24-year career at UBS before jumping ship in 2008, has the crucial Swiss connections needed to succeed in Zurich, he lacks experience in international financial centers such as New York, where Dougan, Shafir and Varvel made their mark.
That is still Dougan’s trump card: Rohner noted recently that he is one of the most experienced CEOs in the industry.
Rohner and Dougan, once rivals for the CEO job, have now settled into a “marriage of convenience,” according to the person familiar with Rohner’s thinking.
A lawyer who made his name as head of German media group Pro Sieben and general counsel of Credit Suisse before taking over as chairman last year, Rohner weighed a slew of alternatives including what one person familiar with the matter described as “the unthinkable”: a UBS-style winding down of fixed income.
But Dougan ultimately convinced Rohner not to take the axe to the investment bank because the chairman was reluctant to make a bolder move, the person close to Rohner said.
“For all his intelligence and acumen, Rohner finds decision-making difficult and hasn’t shown himself to be a visionary thinker,” that person said.
Rohner and Dougan also declined to comment to Reuters.
Though Credit Suisse executives reject the comparison, a key to the bank’s future lies in UBS’s decision to abandon capital-heavy areas of fixed income, a move which has ratcheted up the pressure on European rivals including Barclays (BARC.L) to make similar moves.
“The fact that Credit Suisse constantly references UBS says it all: they’re not coming at this from a position of strength at all,” the former Credit Suisse executive said.
Editing by Emma Thomasson and Anna Willard