RPT - INSIGHT-Ordinary Canadians turn bankers as shadow mortgage lending rises
(Repeats for additional subscribers)
By Andrea Hopkins
TORONTO, July 9 (Reuters) - Canada's housing boom is increasingly driving homebuyers to seek mortgages from private lenders, who demand rates that can be more than five times higher than those charged by the nation's banks.
Canadian house prices have risen 36 percent since June 2009, according to the Teranet-National Bank house price index. At the same time, Canadian banks have become more conservative and regulators are making it harder to lend, giving rise to an alternative market, including Canadians who refinance their own homes at low rates and then use the money to become mortgage lenders themselves.
Some analysts say a housing investment is increasingly risky because the pace of price increases has vastly outstripped wage growth, all amid a time of historically low interest rates and record debt levels. If and when interest rates rise, the concern is that consumers would have little ability to increase their payments, because they have so much debt.
"The risk arises if the unintended consequence of regulation is to push out the risk profile of the less regulated sector, and to encourage it to grow quickly at the same time," said Finn Poschmann, vice-president of policy analysis at the C.D. Howe Institute, a think-tank. "In dollar terms it is not a huge part of the economy (but) my concern is that we pay attention, because small problems sometimes get unexpectedly large, and quickly so."
Mortgage broker Lou Perrotta said that in terms of volume, 20 percent to 30 percent of the mortgages he puts together are now privately financed, typically because borrowers are declined for a bank loan for reasons like a low credit rating or unsteady income. That represents about C$4 million to C$5 million of the C$20 million ($15.69 million) of mortgage business he does annually, he said.
"Business is brisk, without question. (It has) probably tripled in the past three years," said Perrotta, president of Domus Financial Corp in Toronto, where house prices have increased by 55 percent in the last six years.
Perrotta acts as a matchmaker between individuals who have money to lend - and who are seeking higher rates of return than can be had in stocks or bonds - and borrowers who are willing to pay a higher mortgage rate to get into the market. Continued...