June 4, 2014 / 2:18 PM / 4 years ago

Unrepentant on Ukraine, Putin prepares to meet his critics

* Putin to see Western leaders for first time in months

* US and EU have imposed sanctions over Ukraine

* Putin defiant on Ukraine but sanctions start to bite

By Timothy Heritage

MOSCOW, June 4 (Reuters) - Whether he is made to feel like an unwelcome guest or the Prodigal Son returning, Vladimir Putin is relishing the chance to show his defiance over Ukraine at his first meetings with Western leaders in months.

With his ratings soaring at home, the West showing no taste for a fight over Crimea and Europe reluctant to hit Moscow with new sanctions, the Russian president feels he has the upper hand as he sets out for World War Two anniversary events in France.

He also has a point to prove to Barack Obama over comments the U.S. president made last week, suggesting sanctions were deterring the Russian leader from pursuing his policies in Ukraine and that Putin was acting from a position of weakness.

Asked at a conference in St. Petersburg late last month about Obama’s frequent criticisms of him over the Ukraine crisis, Putin replied brusquely: “Who made him the judge?”

The response was typical of a man who, far from cowering under sanctions and clamouring to be welcomed back into the international fold, seems to be revelling in the ideological and geopolitical battle over Ukraine and his campaign to have Moscow treated as an equal by its old Cold War adversaries.

He did not even flinch over a boycott of a G8 summit he had been due to host this week in the Black Sea city of Sochi, intended by the Western members as a protest over Russia’s annexation of the Black Sea peninsula of Crimea.

As the seven others in the Group of Eight industrial powers prepared to meet without him in Brussels, he appeared to be making a point by publicly scheduling his own high-level talks on Wednesday - with officials from the energy industry which gives Russia much of its sway in world affairs.


Putin has good reason to seek an end to the Ukraine crisis; he has achieved key goals - both territorial and in countering NATO - and may see little prospect now of annexing further Russian-speaking areas of eastern and southern Ukraine.

U.S. and European Union visa bans and asset freezes on leading officials and business figures are starting to hurt some in the Russian elite, the economy is sliding into recession and further sanctions could make millions of Russians - still leading life much as usual - start to feel some impact.

But Putin is unlikely to show this at commemorations of the 1944 D-Day landings in Normandy which opened a western front against Nazi Germany as Soviet troops advanced from the east.

Although he will hold his first face-to-face talks with European leaders since the Ukraine crisis worsened in February, when the country’s Moscow-leaning president was overthrown, he has no talks scheduled with Obama or with Ukraine’s newly elected replacement president, Petro Poroshenko.

But those who are due to hold talks with Putin - France’s Francois Hollande, Germany’s Angela Merkel and Britain’s David Cameron - can expect plenty of bravado.

Putin, 61, has deflected every attempt to pin the blame on Russia for the worst standoff with the West since the Cold War - and is likely to read from much the same script in France.

In extracts of an interview with French broadcasters TF1 and Europe 1, the former KGB spy denied Moscow was controlling pro-Russian separatists fighting in east and southeast Ukraine.

Asked if he had tried to annex or destabilise Ukraine, he said: “No, we have never done this and are not doing it.”

Many of his actions in the past few weeks have appeared intended to show sanctions will not isolate Russia.

These included a $400-billion, 30-year gas supply deal signed with China while Putin was visiting Shanghai last month and a treaty he signed last week with two other former Soviet republics, Kazakhstan and Belarus, creating a Eurasian Economic Union to challenge Western economic dominance.

With Obama’s own domestic ratings down, European leaders such as Cameron and Hollande facing political problems, and EU leaders wary of imposing more sanctions because they rely on Russia for energy supplies, Putin will feel confident in France.

The world is unlikely to see “the bored kid in the back of the classroom” that Obama once described Putin as.

Instead, the Kremlin leader will cast himself in two of his most comfortable roles - as the defender of national interests and as the leader of a country which made a major contribution and huge sacrifices in the defeat of Hitler.

Any sign of concessions over Ukraine would be likely to hit his ratings, especially after a surge in patriotism over Crimea.


Behind the scenes, though, Putin may be ready to let the meetings in France sow the seeds of rapprochement with the West.

By reclaiming Crimea, given to Ukraine by Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev in 1954, and exploiting events in Ukraine to undermine the pro-Western leadership and deter Kiev from seeking NATO membership, Putin may have achieved all he can for now.

The West has clearly drawn a line against Russia annexing regions of east Ukraine where separatists are fighting the authorities and Putin has shown no overt support for their cause in recent weeks, even pulling some troops back from the border.

Putin also signalled backing, albeit lukewarm, for the May 25 presidential election won by businessman Poroshenko.

The chances of a compromise being reached in a long-running dispute with Kiev over the price Ukraine pays for Russian gas and bills worth billions of dollars are also increasing.

All that would be threatened if violence in eastern Ukraine got out of control and if Putin came under heavy public pressure at home to send in the army, an option he appears to oppose.

Putin has other reasons to halt the violence in Ukraine, if he still can. Even while mocking Obama at the St. Petersburg conference, he acknowledged sanctions were having an impact.

While many of the country’s political and business elite have rallied behind his attempts to stand up to the West and ensure Russia is treated as an equal partner, many see danger ahead if the crisis drags on and new sanctions are imposed.

“The best-case scenario would include a peace treaty on favourable terms,” said Sergei Karaganov, head of the advisory Council for Foreign and Defence Policy, suggesting this meant Russia keeping Crimea and dominating east and southeast Ukraine without it formally being part of the Russian Federation.

“One thing is for sure; it would be a tragedy if Russia does not use the crisis in relations with the West ... to pursue serious reforms that will speed up its development and create a promising outlook for the nation and its people.” (Editing by Elizabeth Piper and Alastair Macdonald)

0 : 0
  • narrow-browser-and-phone
  • medium-browser-and-portrait-tablet
  • landscape-tablet
  • medium-wide-browser
  • wide-browser-and-larger
  • medium-browser-and-landscape-tablet
  • medium-wide-browser-and-larger
  • above-phone
  • portrait-tablet-and-above
  • above-portrait-tablet
  • landscape-tablet-and-above
  • landscape-tablet-and-medium-wide-browser
  • portrait-tablet-and-below
  • landscape-tablet-and-below