Cautious optimism in Canada energy patch favors light oil producers

CALGARY, Alberta (Reuters) - Canadian light oil producers are in a better position than oil sands heavyweights to benefit from the cautious optimism trickling into the energy industry, thanks to improvements in operating efficiency and two years of steep cost cutting.

An oil rig drills near the Suncor Firebag in-situ oil sands operations near Fort McMurray, Alberta, September 17, 2014. REUTERS/Todd Korol

Companies including Crescent Point Energy and ARC Resources - light oil and natural gas producers - have already upped 2017 capital budgets from this year and others including Encana Corp are expected to follow.

The increases come amid signs the siege mentality that permeated all parts of Canada’s energy industry is lifting after more than two and a half years of slumping prices.

U.S. crude is hovering around $50 a barrel, the weekly western Canadian drilling rig count is up 30 percent on last year, and Calgary’s commercial real estate market just posted its best third quarter in two years.

Increased spending, however, is likely to be concentrated among light oil drilling programs with rapid returns and lower carbon emissions, rather than the multi-billion dollar mega projects in Alberta’s oil sands that drove the last western Canadian energy, analysts say.

“In western Canada outside of oil sands we expect to see activity increase year over year,” said GMP FirstEnergy analyst Mike Dunn. “Their (light oil producers’) spending and activity levels are much more reactive to near-term prices ... the outlook right now is for 2017 to be better than 2016.”

Light oil producers have cut costs around 30 percent by squeezing service providers and improving well completion designs to speed up drilling, according to Wood Mackenzie analyst Mark Oberstoetter, and wells that once cost C$6 million ($4.5 million) to C$7 million to drill can now cost as little as C$4 million.

They can also extract oil from a well in a matter of months, offering more scope to hedge, whereas oil sands projects take two or three years to build.

The oil sands produce 2.4 million barrels per day, 65 percent of Canada’s total crude output, but ARC Financial economist Peter Tertzakian estimates 2017 spending will be down 20 percent on an already weak 2016.

In a note he said capital investment will favor light oil and natural gas producers that offer “bite-sized development, fast investment payback and lower carbon”.

Suncor Energy Inc, Canada’s largest oil and gas producer, said capital expenditure will be C$1 billion lower in 2017 as it nears completion on its Fort Hills mine and offshore Hebron project.

Chief Executive Steve Williams said on an earnings call he did not see the company approving any more major capital projects this decade.

“The oil sands are not in full restart mode. It’s still very cautious,” said Oberstoetter. “The companies that are increasing spending are more your nimble dollars.”

Oil sands projects carry some of the world’s highest full-cycle costs. While those have come down roughly 10 percent since 2014, according to Wood Mackenzie, they still require U.S. crude around $60 a barrel to break even.


A few oil sands producers are taking the plunge, mostly by reinitiating projects that already have capital sunk into them.

Canadian Natural Resources Ltd is restarting its deferred Kirby North thermal plant, while Cenovus Energy Inc is expected to approve Phase G of its Christina Lake project.

Thai company PTT Exploration and Production Pcl has hired Amec Foster Wheeler to do front-end engineering and design work on its Mariana project.

Thomas Grell, Amec’s President of Oil and Gas Americas, said his company was seeing an uptick in inquiries for early stage oil sands work.

“It’s not comparable to the heydays of the market but there’s definitely increased activity,” he said.

($1 = 1.3237 Canadian dollars)

Editing by Marguerita Choy